Impact of Improving Traditional Surface Irrigation Methods on the Physical and Economic Water Productivity of Pomegranate Orchards in Arsanjan, Fars province

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate professor (ph.D.), Agricultural Engineering Research Department, Fars Agricultural and Natural Resources Research and Education Center, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Shiraz, Iran.

2 Assistant professor (ph.D.), Agricultural Engineering Research Department, Fars Agricultural and Natural Resources Research and Education Center, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Shiraz, Iran.

3 Professor., Agricultural Engineering Research Institute (AERI), Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Karaj, Iran

10.22034/iwrj.2026.15338.2677
Abstract
Introduction:

The pomegranate is a significant horticultural crop in arid and semi-arid regions. A substantial portion of pomegranate orchards is located in areas characterized by limited water resources, declining effective rainfall, and severe climatic fluctuations. Under conditions of water scarcity, enhancing water-use efficiency in orchards is not only economically vital for the grower but also serves as a fundamental strategy for alleviating pressure on groundwater resources and ensuring the sustainability of agricultural production. Although pomegranates exhibit relatively good tolerance to water scarcity compared to many other horticultural crops, a lack of water or its improper distribution during sensitive growth stages can lead to stunted fruit development, increased fruit drop, reduced yields, and diminished product quality. Conversely, irrigating beyond the plant's actual requirements does not necessarily boost yield; instead, it can result in unnecessary water consumption due to losses from evaporation, surface runoff, and deep percolation and, in certain conditions, may cause the leaching of water and dissolved salts into the deeper soil layers. Therefore, establishing an optimal irrigation regime requires aligning the volume of water applied, the timing of irrigation, and the method of water distribution with the actual water requirements of the trees. In many pomegranate orchards particularly older one traditional surface irrigation methods are still employed. These methods remain in use due to their simplicity, relatively low initial costs, and compatibility with the existing layout of the orchards. However, they present several potential limitations, including non-uniform water distribution, water losses through evaporation and deep percolation, difficulty in controlling the volume of water applied, and a heavy reliance on the orchard manager's personal experience. Furthermore, with traditional surface irrigation, the timing for shutting off the water flow is typically determined based on empirical criteria; consequently, in many instances, the amount of water introduced into the soil exceeds the actual requirements of the root zone. Under such circumstances, improving irrigation methods does not necessarily entail the complete replacement of traditional practices with a costly system; rather, it can be achieved by refining existing methods, enhancing control over water flow, optimizing the timing of irrigation, utilizing water conveyance pipes, reducing losses during conveyance and distribution, or transitioning gradually toward pressurized irrigation systems. In light of recommendations from previous studies, the present research was conducted to evaluate the impact of modifying irrigation methods and management on the physical and economic water productivity in several pomegranate orchards in the Arsanjan region of Fars province, with the aim of exploring the feasibility of implementing practical management and technical strategies to reduce water consumption and enhance irrigation efficiency in such orchards.

Methods:

Modifications to irrigation methods and scheduling were implemented in a subset of 10 pomegranate orchards in the Arsanjan region of Fars province, which previously relied on traditional surface irrigation. In each orchard, one of five modified irrigation methods improved basin irrigation, border irrigation, furrow irrigation, bubbler irrigation, and low-pressure pipe irrigation was applied alongside the traditional method; specifically, each modified method was implemented in two orchards. In the modified basin irrigation method, the basins were reduced in size to match the area covered by the plant's canopy. In the surface furrow and border irrigation methods, the basin irrigation was converted to furrow irrigation, while the border irrigation was adjusted to the width of the tree canopy. In the low-pressure irrigation system, water was delivered close to the trees via low-pressure pipes. The soil infiltration rate was measured using a double-ring infiltrometer; these data were then used to determine the appropriate irrigation duration and the timing for terminating the irrigation. For the selected orchards utilizing the bubbler irrigation method, the reference crop evapotranspiration was calculated using meteorological data from the local synoptic station, following the FAO Penman-Monteith equation. Subsequently, by applying crop coefficients which were adjusted for the specific region the net water requirement for the pomegranate trees throughout the growing season was determined. Key indicators including yield, irrigation water volume, irrigation water productivity, water application efficiency, actual evapotranspiration, and actual water productivity were measured and compared against corresponding values from control orchards that continued to be managed using traditional irrigation practices. Given the paired structure of the data within each orchard, comparisons between the modified and traditional methods were conducted using a linear mixed model, with the orchard treated as a random effect and the irrigation method as a fixed effect. To determine whether changes to irrigation systems and management practices would be economically viable, a cost-benefit analysis was conducted. For this purpose, total costs including those for crop maintenance, harvesting, irrigation, and the implementation of technologies were estimated for the orchards under study. Gross revenue was calculated by multiplying the product's selling price by the yield obtained in both the treated and control orchards. The net benefit was also calculated and analyzed. Furthermore, the economic productivity of water was assessed. In the study area, some orchards possessed independent water wells, meaning the orchard owners incurred no direct cost for water. Other orchards lacked independent wells and instead purchased water from neighboring farms; in effect, an informal water market had emerged. The average selling price of water was 44,000 Rials per cubic meter. Consequently, the economic analysis was performed under two scenarios: one accounting for the value of water, and the other excluding it.



Results and Discussions:

The results indicated that the average irrigation water applied was 11,187 m³/ha using improved irrigation methods, compared to 15,854 m³/ha using the traditional method. Consequently, the adoption of improved methods resulted in an approximately 29% reduction in irrigation water, a decrease that was statistically significant at the 1% level. Furthermore, the average yield increased from 18,120 kg/ha (traditional method) to 21,000 kg/ha (improved methods)—an increase of 16%, which was also statistically significant at the 1% level. However, no statistically significant differences (at the 5% level) were observed among the five improved methods regarding irrigation water volume or crop yield. When the value of water was excluded from the analysis, net profit, the benefit-cost ratio, and the economic water productivity increased by 111%, 19%, and 188%, respectively; when the value of water was included, these increases rose to 258%, 29%, and 394%, respectively. In summary, the primary advantage of improving traditional irrigation practices in pomegranate orchards as demonstrated in this study was a substantial reduction in irrigation water usage, coupled with higher yields, greater economic profit, and improved physical and economic water productivity; notably, no single improved irrigation method proved to be statistically superior to the others



Conclusion:

It can be concluded that transitioning from traditional irrigation systems to modern methods has had a significant impact on increasing yield and reducing irrigation water volume in the orchards under study. These results highlight the substantial potential of modern irrigation techniques to simultaneously improve production efficiency and water resource management. Although there were numerical differences in yield and water consumption among the five modern methods, these differences were not statistically significant. Furthermore, no significant interaction effect was found between the specific modern method and the irrigation system; this suggests that the general superiority of modern methods over the traditional system followed a relatively consistent pattern across the approaches examined. While some methods yielded the highest output and others achieved the greatest numerical reduction in water consumption, their statistical superiority could not be confirmed. Overall, the research findings underscore the necessity of upgrading traditional irrigation systems and expanding the use of modern methods in the orchards studied. Nevertheless, the selection of an appropriate method should consider not only yield and water savings but also implementation and maintenance costs, soil conditions, and the specific technical characteristics of each orchard. Additionally, conducting studies with a greater number of replicates could facilitate a more precise assessment of performance differences among various modern methods, helping to identify the most suitable option for local conditions.

Keywords

Subjects


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 21 November 2026

  • Receive Date 19 October 2026
  • Revise Date 20 November 2026
  • Accept Date 21 November 2026